Welcome to Orr Valley Creamery—where small-town charm meets big flavor!

Opened in 2022 right in the heart of Orrville, Ohio, Orr Valley Creamery was built on a simple idea: serve up the freshest, creamiest frozen custard around, made with ingredients you can feel good about. Our signature chocolate and vanilla custards are handcrafted daily using locally sourced whole milk and butter straight from Ohio’s Amish Country. That’s how we ensure every scoop is packed with wholesome goodness!

With two locations in both Orrville and Wooster, we've quickly become the go-to spot for families, foodies and anyone who believes dessert should be done right. But we’re more than just custard and ice cream! Our menu also features delicious made-to-order eats and local favorites (like our legendary Guerne Heights Coney!).

Whether you're cruising in for a cone, grabbing dinner with friends or discovering us on a summer road trip, Orr Valley Creamery is your stop for local flavor, friendly faces and a whole lot of sweet memories.

Come taste the difference—and see why everyone’s talking about the Valley!